Santos v. Viscayco

[SEC-SICD * CASE NO. 4271. October 12, 1992.] APOLONIO SANTOS, ET AL. , petitioners , vs . AGING VISCAYCO , respondent . D E C I S I O N Submitted by the parties for approval is a KASUNDUAN (Compromise Agreement) dated October 8, 1992, the pertinent portions of which are quoted hereunder: STcEaI "1. Na ang Samahan Ng Magkakapitbahay Sa Bulelac at Minahan, ay magpapaeleksiyon ng LIMANG OPISYALES na siyang bubuo ng LUPONG PATNUGUTAN, base sa Saligang Batas ng Samahan. Matapos maihalal ang kagawad ng LUPONG PATNUGUTAN sila ay magpupulong at mag hahalal ng tagapangulo, ikalawang pangulo, kalihim, ingat-yaman at tagasuri, at iba pang mga posisyon na kailangan sa Samahan, base sa Artikulo V Seksiyon 1 ng Saligang Batas ng Samahan; 2. Na ang halalan na nabanggit sa unang parapo nito ay gaganapin sa IKA 18 NG OKTUBRE 1992 sa simbahan ng Bulelac, Libis, Malanday, Marikina, M.M., na magsisimula sa alas otso ng umaga (8:00 A.M.) hanggang alas sinko ng hapon (5:00 P.M.); 3. Na ang mamamahala ng halalan o board of canvassers sa halalan ay tatlong (3) teachers, sina: Mrs. Erlinda Lim-it, Mrs. Rose Junio at Mrs. Balachuchi. Ang sino mang ibig na kumandidato ay dapat na mag-file ng kandidatura kay Mrs. Carmencita Cortez, Bulelak, Marikina, M.M. na hindi lalampas ng October 13, 1992 (Deadline); 4. Na, ang mga botante o voters sa halalang ito ay nakatala sa listahan nakalakip dito at pirmado ng bawat panig; 5. Na ang isang botante na nasa labas ng bansa o nasa abroad ay maaaring magtalaga ng kanyang proxy sa pamamagitan ng sulat na may selyo ang sobre ng bansang pinanggalingan; 6. Na, ang pag-"question" sa legalidad ng balota ng botante, ay kailangan na iharap kaagad sa namamahala ng halalan (refer to par. 3, above) at ito ay dapat ng itala sa "minutes" ng halalan at ang namamahala ay siyang gagawa ng hatol sa nasabing tanong o question; 7. Na sino mang botante na nasa talaan ay maaring komandidato sa ano mang posisyon sa Samahan sa halalang ito." and the names of the qualified voters mentioned in item 4 of the said Compromise Agreement are as follows: "SAMAHAN NG MAGKAKAPITBAHAY SA BULELAK AT MINAHAN List of Qualified Voters (Updated as of October 8, 1992) (A) 1. Arandia, Rosalina 2. Almoro, Fernando 3. Almoro, Lucita 4. Almoro, Romeo 5. Almoro, Salud 6. Ancheta, Primitivo 7. Ancheta, Editha 8. Ancheta, Rebecca 9. Ancheta, Jaime 10. Abraham, Herminio 11. Abraham, Rosario 12. Alba, Aquilino 13. Alba, Carmelita 14. Aquino, Teodora 15. Asiatico, Rosita 16. Ambalada, Francisco 17. Abawag, Monina 18. Abat, Nida 19. Aquino, Wilfredo 20. Aquino, Norma (B) 21. Balatbat, Jaime 22. Buracan, Efren 23. Buracan, Lucena 24. Basco, Carmen 25. Balmaceda, Manolo 26. Balmaceda, Lydia 27. Basiao; Susing 28. Baranda, Jose 29. Baranda, Joel 30. Bencalo, Francisco 31. Bencalo, Zuraida (C) 32. Canlas, Martin 33. Canlas, Corazon 34. Canillas, Edison 35. Canillas, Elizabeth 36. Carino, Jaime 37. Cordova, Nene 38. Casa, Francisca, de 39. Cubay, Benjamin 40. Cubay, Alegrina 41. Castaeda, Orlando 42. Castaeda, Celia 43. Cabrera, Lita 44. Cruz, Pampilo 45. Cortez, Rodolfo 46. Cortez, Carmencita 47. Crame, Erlinda 48. Cruz, Ester 49. Cruz, Angelito (D) 50. Dacuba, Eufronio 51. Dacuba, Leonora 52. Divina, Romeo 53. Divina, Angela 54. Dimalanta, Milagros (E) 55. Emperio, Victor 56. Espinas, Mario 57. Espinas, Leticia 58. Espana, Victor 59. Espana, Delia (F) 60. Florendo, Bartolome 61. Florendo, Purita 62. Flores, Claudio 63. Fragata, Gregorio 64. Fragata, Lydia 65. Fragata, Romulo 66. Fragata, Virginia (Maria) 67. Francis, Cesar 68. Francis, Florencia 69. Fuentes, Juanita 70. Fernandez, Marcos 71. Fernandez, Marilou 72. Fernandez, Leonardo 73. Fernandez, Adelina (G) 74. Gabriel, Josefina 75. Guzman, Alfonso de 76. Guzman, Orlando 77. Guzman, Amado de 78. Guzman, Juanita de 79. Guzman, Rosalina de 80. Guzman, Salvador 81. Guzman, Procing de 82. Gragasin, Avelino 83. Gragasin, Violeta (H) 84. Herrera, Wilfredo 85. Herrera, Margarita 86. Herrera, Andres 87. Herrera, Clarita 88. Hipolito, Conchita (I) 89. Iberbia, Anacorita 90. Iberbia, Glaro (J) 91. Jacinto, Carmelita 92. Jacinto, Lazaro 93. Jacinto, Paulino 94. Jacinto, Felina 95. Javier, Rodolfo 96. Jesus, Lilia de 97. Jose, Herminia, San 98. Jose, Vicente San 99. Jose, Alejandra San 100. Junio, Bernardo 101. Junio, Rosita (L) 102. Lanac, Fidel 103. Lanac, Virginia 104. Lim, Clarito, Sr. 105. Lozano, Milagros 106. Lozano, Rodolfo 107. Lozano, Gloria 108. Lozano, Eduardo 109. Luis, Feliciano San 110. Luis, Monina San 111. Ludovice, Paquito 112. Ludovice, Regina 113. Lazaro, Alfredo 114. Lazaro, Aracele (M) 115. Mata, Marcela 116. Maacadat, Nieves 117. Macapagal, Alicia 118. Macapagal, Roque 119. Macapagal, Erlinda 120. Magaan, Salvador 121. Mailed, Aquilina 122. Mailed, Floro 123. Malasarte, Ambrosio 124. Malasarte, Socorro 125. Mallari, Igmidio, Jr. 126. Mallari, Berlina 127. Mamuyac, Clarita 128. Mamuyac, Pedro 129. Manaluz, Anacleta 130. Mangonon, Ernesto, Jr. 131. Mangonon, Genne 132. Manzano, Clara 133. Manzano, Ramon 134. Manalo, Pia 135. Marcelo, Andres, Jr. 136. Marcelo, Artemia 137. Mateo, Mateo 138. Mateo, Silvestre 139. Medillo, Vinacia 140. Miclat, Virginia 141. Miclat, Avelino 142. Mojica, Librada 143. Mojica, Baraquel 144. Muyon, Federico 145. Muyon, Ester 146. Manalo, Pedro 147. Miralles, Vicente 148. Miralles, Dorita 149. Mendoza, Domingo 150. Mendoza, Ma. Buhay (N) 151. Nacum, Marieta 152. Nacum, Villamor 153. Navis, Rolando 154. Navis, Cristina (O) 155. Oamerga, Cesar 156. Ocfemia, Moises 157. Ocfemia, Norma (P) 158. Padua, Santos 159. Padua, Esperanza 160. Pajantoy, Angelina 161. Pajantoy, Maximo 162. Pansuelo, Efren 163. Pansuelo, Elena 164. Pansuelo, Mario 165. Palma, Visitacion 166. Parane, Napoleon 167. Parane, Rosita 168. Paz, Eufronio dela 169. Paz, Purificacion dela 170. Paz, Manolo dela 171. Prado, Manuel del 172. Prado, Luisa del 173. Prado, Isidra del 174. Prado, Rodolfo del 175. Prado, Flora 176. Pereyras, Genaro 177. Prado, Jessie del 178. Prado, Ate del 179. Pereyras, Estelita 180. Pineda, Alejandro 181. Pineda, Arsenio 182. Pineda, Milagros 183. Pineda, Roberto 184. Pineda, Lucrecia 185. Pinuela, Leonila 186. Poblete, Felipe 187. Poblete, Romana (Q) 188. Quitoriano, Apolonio 189. Quitoriano, Leticia (R) 190. Ramolete, Francisco, Jr. 191. Ramolete, Floriano 192. Ramolete, Lolita 193. Rebancos, Herminio 194. Rebancos, Marieta 195. Rebancos, Priscila 196. Resco, Floriano 197. Resco, Visitacion R. 198. Rioboya, Eduardo 199. Rioboya, Mary 200. Roche, Azucena 201. Rosendo, Gloria 202. Roxas, Julita 203. Rioflorido, Natalio 204. Rioflorido, Emily 205. Rubio, Santiago 206 Rubio, Preny 207. Rubio, Gregoria 208. Ruiz, Regina 209. Ruiz, Felicitas 210. Ramolete, Francisco, Jr. 211. Rosario, Rafael, del 212. Rosario, Emma (S) 213. Saculles, Alejandro 214. Saculles, Concepcion 215. Sagun, Damiana 216. Sagun, Ricardo 217. Santos, Apolonio 218. Santos, Teodora 219. Santos, Benjamin 220. Santos, Dominador 221. Santos, Teresita 222. Santos, Paterno 223. Santos, Maura 224. Santos, Librada 225. Santos, Alberto 226. Santos, Romeo 227. Santos, Marieta 228. Salazar, Jose 229. Salazar, Corazon 230. Saforna, Edelfonso 231. Saforna, Gloria 232. Saforna. Jovito 233. Saforna, Fe 234. Sena, Maria 235. Sibol, Corazon 236. Sibol, Corazon 237. Sicat, Jose 238. Sicat, Fely 239. Sequinza, Ernesto 240. Sequinza, Francisca 241. Singson, Lita 242. Solis, Candido 243. Solis, Rosa 244. Solis, Rosita 245. Santos, Pesyang 246. Santos, Conchita 247. Sy, Manuel (T) 248. Tiamzon, Batis 249. Tiamzon, Lory 250. Tiamzon, Celso 251. Tiamzon, Rebecca 252, Ticman, Pedro 253. Tolentino, Rogelio 254. Tolentino, Conchita 255. Tolentino, Angelita 256. Tacuban, Luz (U) 257. Untalan, Luz (V) 258. Valdez, Ricardo 259. Valdez, Loida 260. Vargas, Abelardo 261. Vargas, Nelia 262. Vicente, Francisco 263. Vicente, Celidonia 264. Vito, Pablito 265. Vito, Elizabeth 266. Vizcayno, Pio 267. Vizcayno, Maria 268. Vizcayno, Pepito 269. Vizcayno, Susana 270. Vizcayno, Paladin 271. Vizcayno, Marilou (Z) 272. Zulueta, Manuel 273. Zulueta, Liwayway 274. Zulueta, Bonifacio 275. Zulueta, Maria ADDITIONAL 276. Azuelo, Rodolfo 277. Azuelo, Laura 278. Acupicop, Glen 279. Acupicop, Editha 280. Bautista, Nicolas 281. Baluyot, Danilo 282. Belarmino, Egucerio 283. Doroja, Filipina 284. Interior, Jacinto 285. Garcia, Ricardo 286. Julio, Benjamin 287. Julio, Virginia 288. Macapaga, Milet 289. Mergellano, Bernardo 290. Mergellano, Teresita 291. Acupicop, Patrocenia 292. Abergas, Guillermo 293. Abergas, Julieta 294. Delloson, Edna 295. Mulingbayan, Jorge 296. Belo, Juan 297. Baiz, Exequiel 298. Baiz, Teresa 299. Canaway, Marcelino 300. Canaway. Lourdes 301. Cruz, Felix 302. Mari, Laurentino 303. Equiz, Melencio 304. Equiz, Elena 305. Gawain, Ricardo 306. Gawain, Leonila 307. Geradela, Alejo 308. Ruben, Almario 309. Mrs. Almario 310. Gila, Josephine 311. Ingeniero, Manuel 312. Ingeniero, Gertrudes 313. Intia, Godolfredo 314. Intia, Nelia 315. Javier, Jose 316. Javier, Marieta 317. Jose, Prudencio 318. Jose, Avelina 319. Lopez, Natividad 320. Lopez, Natividad 321. Manalili, Ramon 322. Madiloso, Geralda 323. Maralit, Florencio 324. Maralit, Precila 325. Pavon, Roger 326. Mrs. Pavon 327. Manares, Luz 328. Marin, Alberto 329. Marin, Florencia 330. Miguel, Erlinda 331. Miguel, Melchor 332. Masinsin, Godolfredo 333. Masinsin, Nenita 334. Mendez, Mario 335. Permites, Nicaredo 336. Permites, Normita 337. Palma, Francisco 338. Palma, Marina 339. Pedrano, Concepcion 340. Pedrano, Rodolfo 341. Pedres, David 342. Pedres, Tita 343. Poblete, Milagros 344. Poblete, Eduardo 345. Pascual, Mercedez 346. Pascual, Genoviva 347. Pascual, Guillermo 348. Pedres; Amador 349. Pedres, Lydia 350. Rivera, Ricardo 351. Rivera, Carmelita 352. Reynaldo, Regalado 353. Santos, Nicasio 354. Santos, Lucila 355. Tiamzon, Lualhati 356. Veloso, Gregoria 357. Tiamzon, Onofre 358. Rivera, Melchor 359. Rivera, Gregoria LIST OF VOTERS OF LIBIS BULELAK 360. Alancado, Salvador, Sr. 361. Alancado, Myrna 362. Juantan, Exaltacion 363. Cesar, Paulino 364. Cesar, Cecilia 365. Taburna, Rodolfo 366. Taburna, Pricilia 367. Ruiz, Felicita 368. Ruiz, Gavencio 369. Oamerga, Bernabe 370. Oamerga, Adela 371. Collano, Jorge 372. Collano, Corazon 373. Florencio, Romero, Sr. 374. Florencio, Gregoria 375. Morante, Rogelio 376. Morante, Hermogena 377. Riposo, Norma 378. Lapore, Raymundo 379. Lapore, Cecilia 380. Alipide, Felisa 381. Tauael, Ramon 382. Tauael, Solidad 383. Nava, Marcelo, Jr. 384. Nava, Leonarda 385. Berdaje, Wenceslao 386. Berdaje, Estrella 387. Ronquillo, Mariano 388. Luciano, Romero 389. Luciano, Rowena 390. Perias, Dionisia 391. Mejia, Eduardo 392. Mejia, Anita 393. Cezar, Perfecto 394. Cezar, Salud 395. Cruz, Danilo dela 396. Cruz, Eva dela 397. Indine, Cornefino 398. Indine, Erlinda 399. Vera, Mely de 400. Bajar, Efren 401. Bajar, Norma 402. Berba, Juanito 403. Berba, Milagros 404. Lupdivice, Regina 405. Lupdivice, Paquito 406. Pahayahay, Hercullano 407. Pahayahay, Alma 408. Baflor, Pacita 409. Panayahan, Felipe, Jr. 410. Panayahan, Elisio 411. Panayahan, Adelfa 412. Castillano, Sergio 413. Castillano, Jenirosa 414. Flores, Manuel 415. Flores, Lorena 416. Belarmino, Remedios 417. Belarmino, Glicerio 418. Espidido, William, Sr. 419. Espidido, Teresita 420. Reinda, Jose 421. Reinda, Julieta 422. Lodovice, Narciso 423. Lodovice, Luzbella 424. Lozano, Arturo 425. Lozano, Elena 426. Basiao, Florencio, Sr. 427. Basiao, Filomena 428. Saculles, Alfredo 429. Saculles, Flocerfida 430. Jacob, Dominador 431. Jacob, Myrna 432. Fusilero, Loreto 433. Fusilero, Erlinda 434. Julian, Jacinto 435. Julian, Victoria 436. Paguyo, Ludivico 437. Paguyo, Martina 438. De Gracia, Fernando 439. De Gracia, Narcisa 440. Tapia, Myrna 441. Tapia, Felix 442. Dulpina, Jesus 443. Dulpina, Arcele 444. Jimenez, Nelson 445. Jimenes; Neririta 446. Pajantoy, Danilo 447. Pajantoy, Loida 448. Diolata, Lydia 449. Diolata, Clemente 450. Forten, Norma 451. Forten, Mariano 452. Paching, Felix 453. Paching, Estelita 454. Custodio, Desideria 455. Custodio, Pedro 456. Morquanos, Isagani 457. Morquanos, Alma 458. Pajarito, Danilo 459. Tinediro, Corazon 460. Acebron, Cristobal 461. Acebron, Precentacion 462. Siapco, Bonifacio 463. Siapco, Melani 464. Pioblete, Alfonso" Finding the aforestated Compromise Agreement to be not contrary to law, morals, good customs, public order or public policy, the same should be, as it is hereby APPROVED and DECISION is hereby rendered in accordance therewith. The parties are hereby enjoined to strictly comply with the terms and conditions of the said Compromise Agreement from hereon. EcASIC SO ORDERED. (SGD.) ELPIDIO S. SALGADO Hearing Officer